What Does “No-Kill” Shelter Really Mean?It’s not as simple as you might think.
- Liz Weiner
- Sep 18
- 5 min read
Updated: Oct 7
Contrary to popular belief, there is no idyllic oasis on a remote farm that rescues every hard-to-place animal and invites them to live out the rest of their days frolicking around a picturesque field. And as blissful as it may sound to have an infinite number of these magical fields, it’s not logistically possible, or safe. Over the years I’ve worked in animal rescue, I’ve learned that we can’t save every animal. If you’ve been involved in animal rescue, you probably understand this reality. But for those who aren’t in the weeds of it, I get the sense that the “no-kill” movement is dangerously misunderstood. In practice, shelters and rescues labeled “kill” or “no-kill” work together toward the common goal of helping homeless animals. It’s not an “us” versus “them” mentality.
As someone who volunteers at a county shelter, I am often asked if the shelter is “no-kill.” This question is the bane of my existence. When I let them know it’s not, a horrified look takes over their expression, and they go on to tell me how they could never volunteer for a “kill” shelter. It’s as if they assume the shelter wants to euthanize animals. They don’t. What they want is to do everything in their power to find loving homes for their animals, whether that is with a foster, adopter, or rescue organization — but, they have to operate within the confines of their structure.
Here’s the thing: County shelters (“kill-shelters”) are taxpayer-funded and legally obligated to take in every animal in their jurisdiction, from owner surrenders to strays. They don’t have the option to waitlist or stagger intakes, and are limited by space and budget constraints. When a shelter takes in an animal with a medical or behavioral concern that makes it difficult for that animal to be safely housed in a shelter environment, or they simply don’t have the space for it, they look to place it with a rescue partner.
“No-Kill” shelters and Animal Rescue Organizations are funded by donations and grants, allowing them to set their own admission policies. Rescues are non-profit, volunteer-run organizations that provide a safe space for animals to land in place of the shelter. Because rescue groups typically care for their animals in foster homes, they are better equipped to manage behavioral and medical challenges. Every animal a rescue pulls from a shelter opens up a cage for the next animal that will inevitably show up at that shelter’s door. But the nexts are endless and sometimes hard decisions have to be made.
Before working in animal rescue, I assumed “no-kill” meant a shelter or rescue takes in every animal in need and cares for them until they are adopted. While it’s true that a “no-kill” shelter won’t euthanize an animal (barring medical or behavioral issues that may arise while in their care), there’s a caveat: There’s an admission process. First, they have to get in. While they are incredibly safe havens, like private schools, they have the privilege of selecting the animals they take into their program and can decline admission if they do not have the space, fosters, or financial resources to accommodate them.
In addition to space and other practical constraints, the reality is that not every animal can be rehabilitated. Animal rescue organizations have an obligation to keep their staff, volunteers, and potential adopters safe. Still, the shelter must accept ownership of that dangerous animal, whereas a “no-kill” shelter or rescue can decline admission. Because of their “no-kill” philosophy, they won’t be the party responsible for euthanizing it; thus, the humane euthanasia falls on the county shelter. It is literally in their job description.
Don’t get me wrong, “no-kill” shelters and rescues are the closest thing to that idyllic oasis that exists in the animal rescue world, and millions of lives have been saved because they are in place. But there will always be more animals in need than these organizations can accommodate. The more we are aware of this, the more we may be able to help become part of the solution by supporting rescues, from monetary donations to opening up our homes to foster.
My current dog (along with several other dogs) was pulled from a “kill” shelter in a state 1,300 miles away, and transported to my city, where she resided with her foster until I had the privilege of adopting her. The shelter she came from is in a poor, rural area where adoption rates are low and surrenders are rampant, and has become known as a “high-kill” shelter. This “high-kill” shelter tirelessly sends out desperate pleas to rescues to place their animals, and there are times when they also have to euthanize animals in their care. They are not the ones who caused the overpopulation, but they are left to pick up the pieces.
We are at a point in time where many “kill” shelters have dedicated Foster, Rescue, and Volunteer Coordinators. Instead of shaming them, let’s thank them for everything they do not only to save, but also to enhance the lives of the animals in their care. In my geographical area, shelters are partnering with local businesses to host adoption events — all of the time. Everywhere. Shelter volunteers get the dogs out for walks and socialize the cats and exotic animals. Many local shelters have instituted a program that gives the dogs a break from shelter life by taking them on day-cations or sleepovers. This not only provides an animal with much-needed decompression time, but also helps them get adopted by giving adopters insight into what that animal is like outside of the shelter environment. Before someone surrenders their pet, they are asking, “What would it take for you to be able to keep your pet,” and making them aware of resources available to them in the community, like low-cost vet care and pet food banks.
I'm far from an expert and I can only speak from my lived experience. I’m not naive enough to think that every shelter holds itself to the highest of standards, or that every geographical area has the means to grow its programs, but I’d like to believe we are all doing the best we can with the resources available to us. So when you say you would never volunteer at a “kill” shelter, they are the ones that might need your help the most. They are not the enemy.
Visit my website, Pet Therapy Notes, for resources and more insights on pet love and loss.
Other Essays:
Adopting After Loss:
Rehoming a Pet:
Strained Relationships:
This Isn’t What I Signed Up For: Navigating Emotional and Behavioral Challenges In Pet Relationships
Loss:
Other:
Comments